30 abril, 2012

Economist: Too Liberal, Not Democratic Enough


ECONOMIST: TOO LIBERAL,
 NOT DEMOCRATIC ENOUGH



The French picnic The Economist abhors.
(adapted from Edouard Manet’s “The Picnic”)

in “The Economist”, 31 March 2012


“The Economist” is a prestigious British journal and a staunch defender and promoter of liberty and Liberalism. I used to be a subscriber and still am a regular on-line reader.

A few reasons shifted me away from “The Economist”. The relevant one for the purposes of this post, relates to what I view as being a fundamentalist drift on the journal’s defence of its ideals.

It started by The Economist’s 2008 endorsement of Barack Obama’s candidacy for the office of President. Although the candidate espoused several views that ran counter The Economist’s convictions, especially on trade, this journal expressed its confidence that Obama would flip flop on these issues once elected. Besides this odd conviction, there was the funny detail that John McCain was not awarded the same confidence, or lack hereof.

However, it is another election that drives me to write this post: the 2012 French Presidential election. In fact, “The Economist” has run an interesting series of articles and analysis of the French political and especially economic situation, as well as the potential impact of the elections on other European states and on the euro.

The problem is that “The Economist” has fallen into trading democratic accountability, loyalty and the need for a honest relationship between the elected and the elected for the blind pursuit of its own agenda:

Many business leaders cling to the hope that a certain worldly realism will emerge. [….] once elected, the new president will ditch his extravagant promises and pursue a sensible agenda of reform, [….]. But is that really possible? It would be hard for Mr Sarkozy suddenly to propose deep public-spending cuts, given all the things he has said. It would be harder still for Mr Hollande to drop his 75% tax rate.

Besides, there is a more worrying possibility than insincerity. The candidates may actually mean what they say. And with Mr Hollande, who after all is still the most likely victor, that could have dramatic consequences.
in “The Economist”, A Country in Denial,

So, “The Economist” recommends and hopes that French politicians scrap everything they said on the campaign trail and follow The Economist’s agenda, or Merkel’s, or whoever’s. Worse than lying, the elected candidate could be tearing The Economist’s bible apart! Dear God!

And this was not just an unfortunate tirade by an overzealous journalist. A month later, they were at it again:
Optimists [….]  dismiss as symbolic Mr Hollande’s flashy promises to impose a 75% top income-tax rate and to reverse Mr Sarkozy’s rise in the pension age from 60 to 62, arguing that the 75% would affect almost nobody and the pension rollback would benefit very few. They see a pragmatist who will be corralled into good behaviour by Germany and by investors worried about France’s creditworthiness.
If so, no one would be happier than this newspaper. But it seems very optimistic to presume that somehow, despite what he has said, despite even what he intends, Mr Hollande will end up doing the right thing.
in “The Economist”, The Rather Dangerous Monsieur Hollande, at http://www.economist.com/node/21553446  

It is amazing! Corralled, tamed, maybe chained and enslaved to “The Economist” and to a foreign power, that is what would make “The Economist” happy after the May runoff! How undemocratic and arrogant!

13 comentários:

Eduardo Ribeiro disse...

Just look at this as another show of British snobish behaviour towards everything and everybody non-British. They often insist on dreaming with the kind of world they knew - and ruled over - in the past!

Defreitas disse...

Not sure which is worse; french politicians (both sides) who want to ensure that they can blame the other side for any possible downturn after the election, or the pathetic british politicians whose only 'ray of light is to wait till the EU take the necesary steps to lauch a fight for economic growth, instead of austerity !

British never take risks : The Euro ? No thank you ! The fiscal off-shore paradises ? Yes, please ! The tax on financial speclative trade ? No, thank you ! And so on !!!!

Hollande will push for some very positive steps on theses matters! This will not be good for the City! . This is why the “The Economist” lauch this attack on this week cover!

Even with an independent Bank and an independent Currency, british economy enters now in recession !

Hollande target is economic growth, indeed! And he is right. Other conutries will follow his idea!

For everyone and every business that, falling victim to anxiety, cuts back spending any more than is absolutely necessary, is guilty of aggravating our problems. My or your reduction in spending is other people's reduction in income. That can only serve to make matters worse. Look on Portugal ! and Spain !
So, let us at all costs avoid being stingy. So far as circumstances permit, let us behave normally; even spend as much as possible!! For that is the way to economic recovery.
British PM decision to send back home sick people from hospitals to reduce expenses, is not the solution !


Freitas Pereira

Defreitas disse...

Not sure which is worse; french politicians (both sides) who want to ensure that they can blame the other side for any possible downturn after the election, or the pathetic british politicians whose only 'ray of light is to wait till the EU take the necesary steps to lauch a fight for economic growth, instead of austerity !

British never take risks : The Euro ? No thank you ! The fiscal off-shore paradises ? Yes, please ! The tax on financial speclative trade ? No, thank you ! And so on !!!!

Hollande will push for some very positive steps on theses matters! This will not be good for the City! . This is why the “The Economist” lauch this attack on this week cover!

Even with an independent Bank and an independent Currency, british economy enters now in recession !

Hollande target is to economic growth, indeed! And he is right. Other conutries will follow his idea!

For everyone and every business that, falling victim to anxiety, cuts back spending any more than is absolutely necessary, is guilty of aggravating our problems. My or your reduction in spending is other people's reduction in income. That can only serve to make matters worse. Look on Portugal ! and Spain !
So, let us at all costs avoid being stingy. So far as circumstances permit, let us behave normally; even spend as much as possible!! For that is the way to economic recovery.
British PM decision to send back home sick people from hospitals to reduce expenses, is not the solution !

Freitas Pereira

Defreitas disse...

O meu comentário original é em Inglês. Saiu em Francês, mas típico duma tradução automática do Google ! I’m sorry !

Freitas Pereira

Ricardo Mendes Ribeiro disse...

This is the best comment you produced for several months. Congratulations.

Rui Miguel Ribeiro disse...

Eduardo,
I had to write in English to finally have te pleasure of your visit.
As for the comment, being an unconditional Anglophile, I cannot subscribe to it!

Rui Miguel Ribeiro disse...

Daer Mr. De Freitas,
It is always good to have you around.
I agree with you on the emphasis on growth. This insane austerity is killing the economy. However, this should be accomplished via a tax reduction for business and people, so that both investment and spending could increase.
I'm afraid I cannot go around spending more than strictly necessary: I have 3 children and we (especially my wife) have suffered severe cuts in pay, coupled with brutal increases in taxes and fundamental itens like electricity, gas and others through VAT increases. This is the result not of British policies but of Germany's fiscal Diktat!

Rui Miguel Ribeiro disse...

Thank you Bro!

That was very nice of you (I hope!)!

Anónimo disse...

Aw, this was a very nice post. In thought I want to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and precise effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and not at all seem to get one thing done.

Anónimo disse...

I'd like to thank you for the efforts you have put in writing this website. I'm hoping to see the same high-grade content by you in the
future as well. In fact, your creative writing abilities has encouraged
me to get my very own site now ;)
My weblog : PanicAway

Anónimo disse...

Hi there! Тhіs is my 1ѕt cоmmеnt heгe so I just wanted to give
а quiсk ѕhout out anԁ tell уou I truly еnjοy гeadіng
youг aгticlеs. Cаn you suggеst аny other blogѕ/webѕites/forums
that covеr the sаme topics? Thanκ you!

Cheсk out mу blog: cost to build a boat

Anónimo disse...

Hеy! This iѕ my first сomment
here ѕо I јust wantеd to give a quіck shout out and saу
I trulу enjoy reaԁing through youг
artісles. Can yοu гecommend any other blogs/ωebsitеs/forums that ԁeal ωith thе sаme subjects?
Thank you!

Here is my ωebsitе ... bigger leap

Anónimo disse...

Tоday, I went tο the bеaсhfгοnt with my κidѕ.
I found a sеa shell and gave іt to my 4 yeаr old
ԁaughter and saiԁ "You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear." She
ρut the shell to hеr eаr and sсreаmed.
Theгe wаs a hermit crab inside аnd it pinсhed her ear.
She never wаnts to go baсk! LοL I κnow thіѕ is totally off topic
but I hаd to tell someone!

Αlѕо visit my weblog ... dream holiday